Kina og Japan står ikke foran brandudsalg af US treasuries

Dette indlæg er mere end 500 dage gammelt. Markedsforhold, priser, regler mv. kan have ændret sig, siden jeg skrev indlægget.

Det amerikanske gældsloft får rigelig omtale. Tre pointer, der er værd at hæfte sig ved:

1. Selvom Reuters i august skrev, at Kina og Japan har solgt kraftigt ud af deres beholdninger af amerikanske statsobligationer – måske på grund af inflationsfrygt eller default risk – så viser Federal Reserve’s egne tal, at faldet i juni 2013 mere ligner et almindeligt udsving end et brandudsalg. Kina og Japan er stadig langt (!) de største udenlandske ejere af amerikanske treasuries.

2. En amerikansk default fører næppe til at Kina og Japan kaster deres statsobligationer fra den ene dag til den anden, da den amerikanske dollar helst ikke skal blive for billig over for kinesiske yuan og japanske yen. Se f.eks. denne forklaring fra Mathew Klein ovre på Bloomberg:

Profit-seeking investors would rightly try to get their money out of a country with such dysfunctional political institutions by selling every dollar-denominated asset they own. The Federal Reserve could offset the impact of these sales on domestic interest rates, but the exchange value of the U.S. currency would plunge against our trading partners. That would be great for U.S. exporters but disastrous for anyone outside the U.S. who wants to sell things to American consumers and businesses. Many countries would feel compelled to intervene and offset the actions of their (and our) private citizens. The seemingly bizarre implication is that China and Japan would probably end up buying far more dollar-denominated assets after a U.S. government default than they do right now.

3. En amerikansk default behøver ikke medføre tab af cash flow i den private sektor. Federal Reserve har ret til at købe obligationer garanteret af den amerikanske stat – uafhængigt værdien af denne garanti. Ergo, kan de købe fra den private sektor og holde dem ind til en betaling formentlig vil finde sted. Sådan lyder det ifølge en kommentar fra Deutsche Bank, der blev citeret på FT Alphaville:

What could the Fed do to promote financial stability? First, the Fed could purchase defaulted Treasury securities. There is nothing immediately evident in the Federal Reserve Act that would preclude the Fed from this action. That is, these securities would still qualify for purchase under Section 14 of the Federal Reserve Act because they would still be guaranteed by the US Government, even if that guarantee weren’t able to be acted on fully for a time. Those securities and accumulated interest would be redeemed at some point.

Photo credits: Wuyouyuan
Photo credits: Wuyouyuan

Sommerlæsning: Historien om Japans økonomiske boble og dens konsekvenser

Dette indlæg er mere end 500 dage gammelt. Markedsforhold, priser, regler mv. kan have ændret sig, siden jeg skrev indlægget.

På trods af finanskrisen anno 2008 på vores breddegrader kan man ikke undgå at blive overrasket og forundret over den heftige boble, Japan oplevede i 1980’erne, og efterdønningerne:

By 2004, residential real estate in Tokyo was only worth of 10% of its late 1980s peak, while the most expensive land in Tokyo’s Ginza business district had fallen back to just 1% of its 1989 level in the same year (Barsky, 2009). Similarly, the Nikkei stock index is now trading around 10,000, just little over a quarter of its all-time high. It has been over two decades since the popping of Japan’s economic bubble and the country is still actively battling with deflationary forces that are so powerful that near-zero interest rates (zero-interest rate policy or ZIRP), repeated bouts of quantitative easing (some call it “money printing”) and constant Yen-weakening currency interventions have barely made a dent.

Citatet er fra artiklen Japan’s Bubble Economy of the 1980s, som bestemt er værd at læse. Når man læser om Japans historie, er det også svært ikke at sammenligne med Kina, hvor landets virksomheder og befolkning samler så meget velstand at de køber vestlige virksomheder.

Japan’s Bubble Economy of the 1980s
The Bubble Bubble, Jesse Colombo